
The Royal Highlanders was an American fraternal benefit society with a Scottish theme. According to History Nebraska (the Nebraska State Historical Society), its first lodge, which it called a “castle”, was organised by F. J. Sharp in 1895 at Aurora, Hamilton County, Nebraska, and the society was chartered on 10 August 1896. Its headquarters building in Aurora was said to be modelled on Balmoral Castle in Scotland.
Its stated goal was “to unite for mutual benefit and fraternal protection all white persons who are in good health, of exemplary character, and between the ages of 16 and 65”. Men and women joined on equal terms. Arthur Preuss recorded 375 lodges and 20,768 benefit members in the early 1920s, with its “Executive Castle” by then in Lincoln, Nebraska, and noted that its ceremonies drew on Scottish history.
Like many such societies it gradually became an ordinary insurance company. History Nebraska records that in 1937 it took the name Mutual Legal Reserve Life Insurance Company, and later traded as Lincoln Mutual Life Insurance Company and Lincoln Direct Life Insurance Company. Its policy and death records from 1897 to 1930 are now kept by History Nebraska.
Is it connected with Freemasonry? No. The Royal Highlanders used castles and Scottish titles, but it was an independent life-insurance fraternity, not part of Freemasonry or of any Masonic rite. The Royal Highlanders are Non-Masonic.
Sources:
History Nebraska, “The Royal Highlanders”, archived copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20250807040504/https://history.nebraska.gov/the-royal-highlanders/
History Nebraska, “Royal Highlanders (Aurora, Neb.) [RG3962.AM]”, archived copy: https://web.archive.org/web/20200923185341/https://history.nebraska.gov/collections/royal-highlanders-aurora-neb-rg3962am
Arthur Preuss, A Dictionary of Secret and Other Societies (St. Louis, 1924): https://archive.org/details/PreussPDF