Loyal Mystic Legion of America

Emblem of Loyal Mystic Legion of America

The Loyal Mystic Legion of America was a fraternal benefit society of the kind that flourished in the United States around 1900: a secret order with lodges, a ritual and officers, whose main business was insuring the lives of its members. Its governing body, the supreme council, sat at Hastings, Nebraska, and it organised local branches, called subordinate councils, in other States. Its members were known in its ritual as “companions”.

Most of what is known about it today comes from a case it fought in the Nebraska Supreme Court, Loyal Mystic Legion of America v. Richardson (1906). In November 1901 one of its deputies recruited members at Fort Collins, Colorado, and sent their applications to the supreme council at Hastings. One applicant, Charles C. Richardson, was killed in an accident a few days after the new council was organised, before he had been initiated. His mother sued for the $1,000 benefit. The court ruled for the society, holding that under its constitution and by-laws Richardson had never become a member.

The case shows how these societies worked: benefit certificates, regular assessments paid into a benefit fund, and membership that began only with initiation. Albert C. Stevens’s Cyclopædia of Fraternities lists the Legion among the many beneficiary orders of its day.

The Loyal Mystic Legion of America was not Masonic. It was an insurance fraternity with its own constitution and governing council, entirely separate from Freemasonry.

Sources:
Loyal Mystic Legion of America v. Richardson, 76 Neb. 562 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1906): https://hallapproved.com/ne/cases/supreme/1906/6773788/
Albert C. Stevens, The Cyclopædia of Fraternities, 2nd ed. (New York: E. B. Treat, 1907): https://archive.org/details/cyclopdiaoffrate00stev_0, membership table of beneficiary orders