
The Ancient Order of Knights of the Mystic Chain is an American fraternal society. Albert Stevens’s Cyclopaedia of Fraternities (1907) records that it “was founded at Reading, Pa., February 2, 1871, by John O. Matthew, locomotive engineer on the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad, and John M. Brown, merchant.” At its first initiation ceremony twenty-one Knights of Pythias joined.
Its stated purposes were to relieve members in sickness, accident or distress, to help them in business and in finding work, to care for the widows and orphans of members, to foster love of country and home, and to teach obedience to the laws. “Partisanship and sectarianism are excluded,” Stevens notes, and the order’s motto is “Loyalty, Obedience, and Fidelity”. Its local bodies are called castles, and eighteen years after its founding it added an insurance feature like many other societies of the time.
How is it connected with Freemasonry? It is a separate fraternal order, not part of Freemasonry. Stevens records that “Both founders were Freemasons”, and that its emblem, with the All-Seeing Eye over the Bible upon an altar, shows Masonic influence, yet he compares the order itself with the Odd Fellows and Foresters, which “differ from Freemasonry”.
Sources:
Albert C. Stevens, The Cyclopædia of Fraternities, 2nd ed. (New York: E. B. Treat, 1907): https://archive.org/details/cyclopdiaoffrate00stev_0, entry “Ancient Order, Knights of the Mystic Chain”