CONSPIRACY CLAIM #48

The claim

CLAIM #48:
The Freemasons faked the moon landing, and Buzz Aldrin being a Mason proves it?

FALSE

ANSWER:
The Moon landings happened, and the evidence is still sitting on the Moon. Buzz Aldrin was indeed a Freemason, which proves exactly one thing: that a Freemason went to the Moon.

Astronaut Buzz Aldrin in his white spacesuit standing on the grey surface of the Moon during the Apollo 11 moonwalk
Buzz Aldrin on the Moon during the Apollo 11 moonwalk, July 1969. Photo: Neil Armstrong, NASA. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Two old conspiracy theories meet in this one. The first is that the Apollo Moon landings were staged, an idea that, as the Encyclopaedia Britannica explains, feeds mainly on distrust of the US government. The second is that NASA is a Masonic operation. Put them together and you get the claim that the landings were a Masonic hoax, or even a Masonic “ritual”, and the proof offered is that Buzz Aldrin, the second man to walk on the Moon, was a Freemason.

Was Buzz Aldrin a Freemason?

Official NASA portrait of astronaut Buzz Aldrin in his spacesuit, holding his helmet, with a large image of the Moon behind him
Edwin “Buzz” Aldrin, lunar module pilot of Apollo 11, in his official NASA portrait. NASA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Yes, and nobody in Freemasonry has ever been shy about it. Greg Stewart’s What is Freemasonry? records that Aldrin was made a Mason at Montclair Lodge No. 144 in New Jersey, and Masonic sources list him as a member of Clear Lake Lodge No. 1417 in Seabrook, Texas. Astronauts were allowed to take a few personal items with them, and Aldrin took an embroidered flag bearing the emblem of the Scottish Rite, Southern Jurisdiction. He also carried, as the Grand Lodge of California’s magazine puts it, “a special deputation from then–grand master of Texas J. Guy Smith authorizing him to claim Masonic territorial jurisdiction on the moon on behalf of the Grand Lodge of Texas.”

That last item is the one conspiracy videos love, so let us be precise about it. It was a fraternal gesture, the Masonic equivalent of a school pennant taken along for luck. It gave nobody any power over the Moon, NASA or anything else, and the lodge that commemorates it, Tranquility Lodge No. 2000, has kept the joke going with a straight face ever since: it “is based in Texas under the auspices of the Grand Lodge of Texas until such time as the Lodge may hold its meetings on the Moon.” For the record, Neil Armstrong, the first man on the Moon, was not a Freemason; his father was.

Does a Mason on the crew prove a hoax?

Think about what the claim is asking you to believe. If the landing had been faked, a Masonic flag and a Grand Master’s letter in an astronaut’s pocket would be pointless props in a film studio. They only make sense if a man who was proud of his lodge was actually going to the Moon. Aldrin’s Masonic souvenirs are, if anything, a small piece of evidence that he went.

Webmaster’s note: Let us savour this one, because it is a genuine masterpiece of the genre. According to the people who spread it, the Moon landing never happened: it was filmed on a sound stage, very possibly by Freemasons. According to the very same people, often in the very same video, Buzz Aldrin used his time on the Moon to carry out a secret Masonic rite, unfurling the lodge’s flag and claiming the Moon for the Grand Lodge of Texas. So which is it, gentlemen? Either nobody went to the Moon, in which case nothing Masonic happened there, or something Masonic happened there, in which case somebody had to be standing on it. You cannot fake a trip and then get upset about what was done on arrival. Believing both at once is not research; it is the mental equivalent of insisting the Moon is made of cheese while also complaining that the Freemasons ate it. It takes a very special kind of genius to accuse the Masons of faking a journey in the same breath as accusing them of taking it, and the folk who peddle this to smear the fraternity have managed it without once noticing. We would explain it to them again, slowly, but we suspect they would only ask whether the explanation was filmed in a studio too.

More to the point, one member’s personal pride is not the policy of a fraternity. Aldrin flew as a NASA astronaut, not as an envoy of a lodge, and nothing suggests that any Grand Lodge ever had a say in the space programme. Freemasonry did not plan, fund, run or fake anything at NASA; a Mason simply happened to be in the crew, just as Masons have been doctors, plumbers and presidents.

How do we know the landing was real?

The Apollo 11 laser-ranging retroreflector, a square panel of small mirrors, resting on the lunar surface
The laser reflector left on the Moon by Apollo 11. Scientists still bounce lasers off it from Earth. Photo: NASA (AS11-40-5952). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Because the Apollo crews left things behind, and they are still there. In 2009, forty years after the landing, NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter photographed the descent stage of the Apollo 11 lunar module, the Eagle, sitting where it was left. Its pictures show the shadows of the flags still standing at the Apollo 12, 16 and 17 sites, according to NASA’s Apollo Lunar Surface Journal; Apollo 11’s flag is not standing, which is just what Aldrin reported, since he “looked up long enough to see the flag fall over” as they lifted off. Probes from India and Japan have photographed the landing sites as well, and those photographs show the tracks the astronauts left behind.

The missions were also watched as they happened by people with every reason to expose a fake: Soviet military intelligence tracked the Apollo flights, the Jodrell Bank radio telescope in England followed the Eagle’s landing, and the Bochum observatory in Germany could hear the voices of Armstrong and Aldrin. And Apollo 11, 14 and 15 left mirrors on the Moon, called retroreflectors, at which scientists have been aiming laser beams since 1969 to measure the distance between the Earth and the Moon. A studio in Hollywood would be a very long way to aim.

Conclusion: The Moon landings were real, and they were not faked by Freemasons or anyone else. Buzz Aldrin was a Freemason of Clear Lake Lodge No. 1417, Texas, and he took a Scottish Rite flag and a playful Grand Lodge “deputation” with him. Those were one member’s souvenirs, not Masonic control of NASA, and they only make sense because he really went. The descent stage, the flags, the tracks and the laser reflectors are still on the Moon to prove it.